very high standard hotel , good parking very good rooms and the breakfast was excellent.

all round great stay and perfect for golf location over looking gullane gc

excellent service wonderful staff breakfast great choice

breakfast was delicious, had full scottish breakfast which set us up for the day

location, next to golf course, we were early and there was no problems with check-in

and if you were a golfer and the b&b experience was not the focus of your time there

the broc bar and the stables restaurant are very comfortable and very friendly with excellent service

was perfect for scottish golf open, breakfast was great, cooked to order and the granola was best i have tasted

friendly staff, small and intimate atmosphere, great outside space with a bar and fire

complaint sitting at window in bar a slight draft

the bar has good selection of beers and whiskys ( lively pint poured ) but the best part about the

locals in the bar area were also friendly and welcoming and i will definitely return

walking through bar and restaurant to book into the room

very limited parking outside

the free wifi was absolutely dreadful ok in the bar but upstairs in the rooms not good at all.

choice of cooked breakfast, with quality products- especially the haggis with the full scottish breakfast

traditional style building, friendly and helpful staff, nice lounge, good parking.

given all breakfast options - cereal on the side and hot breakfast if needed

great breakfast

both dinner and breakfast were enjoyable

there were no instructions about how to access the wifi or use the coffee maker

spaciousness, ample free parking, views

the spa facilities would benefit from being upgraded

great pool, gym & spa area

a la carte breakfast which is perfect

staff in bar and restaurant very friendly and extremely helpful

friendly staff, good sized room, bar and bistro below

everything clean and wow factor in bistro , garden extension, bar

friendly, bar and bistro on site, sadly arrived too late to enjoy a meal, but plenty of local takeaways of

lovely restaurant and bar lounge which also sold food, we ate in both and food was delicious

brilliant spa facilities

easy parking and wifi

with large sized bedrooms, and options for single rooms for kids who are too old to share

after a cold rainy day out sightseeing we enjoyed the gym & the heated pool with spa

of edinburgh, room was nice and tidy well maintained and the staff were very good we arrived early to park the

restaurant food was delicious but the quantity of it was ridiculous it was like a kids portion and definitely

plenty of parking

also very handy for the local golf course

possibly a small gym or pool would be nice, but i'm not sure it's logistically possible

staff were brilliant, room was nice, parking and wifi good

spotlessly clean room. very helpful and friendly staff. good bar and food onsite.

especially happy when we discovered that we had a lovely quiet room away from any noise in the bar area

really nice bar and food

wifi is a bit weak as

all the girls at reception and bar are so nice and have made leven a great place to visit

a little thing from us, the wifi was not smooth

wifi a little bit patchy

comfy bed, big window, tv, wifi, had everything i needed

great location, clean, free wifi, free on street parking.

good wifi connection

the dinner and breakfast were of the highest quality and standard

fingal is a great experience all round and breakfast is worth a mention to

breakfast, so very disappointing

i highly recommend the brulee porridge with whiskey for breakfast

no spa or swimming pool

excellent location, good parking and sky tv

love the malmaison because it is pet friendly

shame gym not open yet also limited times available to book breakfast slots.

there s plenty of parking which is free and two minutes walk to the tram stop to go in the centre of edinburgh

an industrial noise like a laundry or something similar

continental breakfast served in the bridge bar was lovely with a good selection- other half loved the smoked

good wifi

the breakfast was great and super unexpected

friendly experience and our kids loved the history of the boat

or move into position to use its a shame that, at 10am, bowls of fruit weren't available at breakfast ( they

ideal for golf, but with only three rooms, could easily be booked up.

plenty of parking spaces

hotel was lovely staff very friendly ideal location to the golf at st andrews

however because the bathroom is next to the kitchen, i could hear the staff talking to each other - voices

in the kitchen i couldn't find a sieve for straining the rice

was a very odd unpleasant smell in the kids room

staff went above and beyond to get us an early check in because of our early flight

lack of laundry facilities

there are lots of kids just hanging around outside and screaming and shouting

no laundry machines. no ice machines.

the wifi was poor, they know it was poor - intermittent

wifi

all things regarding your stay including the process for checking in, checking out, connecting to wifi, contact

the handbook online provides all the information you need to access the hotel, your room, wifi logon details

our request for early check in as attending a wedding

noisy from footsteps upstairs..floor not insulated well enough ..young kids struggled to settle

place where you eat melville inn the selection of foods if you have kids there isn't great small dislike as this

wifi reception awful

wifi connection was super strong and reliable and the in-room air conditioning is excellent & super

would have liked an extra pillow and wifi details in room.

no access to kitchen / kettle

kitchen available which can be used

wifi availability

stay was so good a compact neat and tidy room particularly the kitchen with microwave,fridge wish i could stay

poor wifi away from public spaces.

wifi not very good

plenty of parking spaces and within walking distance into town

we came from lanarkshire and asked for an early check in which was honoured

no room service

i was a single guy travelling with my 2 young kids (7&4) the staff couldn't do enough for you and the beds were

the welcome and laundry.

com there is always something not right i stipulate on all bookings 1, parking 2, bathroom not shared not hard

very friendly staff good bar good value for money

look welcoming, tidy on the outside, free parking to the rear of the building

the kitchen in the suite was also very clean and

wifi didn t work in the yard.

was in an ideal location and with kitchen facilities and also laundry facilities it was great

even laundry detergent was given for free

freedom with multiple exits/entrances comes with the a kitchen we went for the spice girls and they were very

fees on wifi, parking is not the properties' but the street's (though it is unrestructed and confortable)

enought for the price, all was clean, we had towels, hairdryer, soap, the stuff was nice, working wifi, comfortable

very good service, the beds are comfortable but it doesn t include wifi :/

hoy need to pay extra for the wifi per night, it's not include as the website says.

clean, warm, ensuite, wifi, and great value for money

parking, easy check in, very clean room, lovely service from the staff

the room service was good

location is perfect for us, good parking, only a short walk to town centre and close to train station to access

wifi in room was not working.

wifi was slow in our room.

wifi was tempermental at times, maybe becuase we were in the garden room and far from the router

wifi weak downstairs

really close to the center, delicious breakfast and wonderful staff

clean, amazing facilities - comfy bed also. beautiful breakfast room

wifi was poor throughout the property

wifi worked well

kitchen was also clean

like kitchen things, iron boards, laundry room are easily accessible

i was just there for one night and so it was handy to have access to a kitchen so that i could use the fridge

having the self-serve laundry facilities in a separate building from the residence also worked very well

near city good kitchen

wifi a bit slow. a bit noisy at night (from other guests not outside)

anyone is expecting to use the kitchen to cook in, note that there is very little equipment and so meals would

the location was good and the fact of having a kitchen was a good option as well.

the instruction in the laundry room isn't very clear

no wifi

charge on wifi

poor wifi

wifi was erratic, couldn t work on social media( probably not a bad thing)

the wifi was weak or not existent in some of the rooms, that's the only thing i did not like.

beautiful hot breakfast, good range /choice.

lack of room service

good choice of continental breakfast delivered to room. lovely, spacious, clean rooms.

attentive hosts ideal continental breakfast with good choices free wifi room excellent location for venturing

also during my stay, the last two days there were kids downstairs you can hear them playing loudly

they do provide laundry service to a company in town, but you pay for each article

the staff were very friendly and had a lovely breakfast buffet and fab restaurant and bar

room was available for early check

ideal for families of 2 adults, 2 kids

the bathtub was clean and the kids loved it

wifi in brochure says no pass key required but info sent by owners gives password

15 minutes bus to city centre, off street car parking, friendly service. covid ready.

the guest house had stabile wifi and consistent warm water

the staff were lovely and so helpful, breakfast was great, there was free parking and the room was lovely,

easy, free parking

reception was kind enough to give us late check out while we were waiting for our train back

pool and spa area very pleasant

information in room concerning air con,room service,laundry etc

we asked for early check in as our flight was so early this wasn t accommodated at all staff said they would

bar area stunning and staff were outstanding

layout, bathroom, kitchen, den, bedding, cleanliness, location, decor, this property has it all

we did not book breakfast but there was muesli, bread,jam and butter in the kitchen as well as coffee,tea and

the noise from the restaurant/kitchen upstairs until 1am

basement room with own kitchen facilities (no cooker but good microwave), washing machine, dishwasher & fridge

staff very efficient and friendly and organised an early check in

great little gym

the gym was small but functional

perhaps a later room service for food as the play finished and we came home there was no food service available

room was nice and clean. breakfast was great. staff excellent.

early check in, smart room, lovely bar and breakfast room

was terrible and very bad for ppl with kids or those not liking stairs

lovely bar area

perfect. cocktail bar staff were amazing. receptionists polite helpful and made us feel at home.

hotel, stunning rooms and roof garden, staff excellent and even room service food was good

the price for the location and parking was excellent

no laundry service. helpless stuff at reception

cleanliness and size of the rooms, quality of the food, friendly staff, early check in and free parking

wifi connection and quality

only downside was wifi wouldn't

there is a nice trust bar on the ground floor

special shout out to tulgeran (i hope i got the spelling right) who mans the bar area , and achilles

mini bar or room service menu - not traffic to go to the bar to collect drinks but would have been a delicious

nice pet friendly hotel - beds, bows and treats, our room was on the first floor next to the bar and we were

wasn t room service or onsite bar/restaurant until 5pm, but the staff were so friendly, this was hardly a

the sofa bed was ok-ish for kids but not very solid for adults.

room we stayed has a layout that suits for a family with kids

wifi wasn't working and breakfast not available

sofa bed was probably slightly too small for our two kids to share now they are getting older

wifi laptop and phone both are fail to connect to wifi staff said there is nothing he could

seemed to have some difficulty with connecting to the wifi on the upper floor, and the toilet flusher in our

only criticism was no parking. but plenty around streets at back of hotel

the wifi is also terrible, which i don't normally care about, but i had to take a scheduled work video

parking is easy and it s convenient to take buses to city center

included cereals, juice, toasted bread, croissants, fruits, yogurt, scrambled eggs and hot drinks parking was

the breakfast was an added bonus and we would stay longer next time because of the pet friendly policy

location, breakfast, rooms good and free wifi

it very noisey from 6am,laundry getting delivered right under our window

really hotels fault, but a family was bashing doors as their kids ran between two rooms - the reception did talk

the free refreshments bar in reception is a nice touch

the apartment was very well equipped and the on-site laundry facilities were a wonderful bonus.

tv channels were very basic but we did have free wifi so we didn't find this much of an issue

the apartment was very comfortable, with a separate room for my kids to sleep in

nice communal area with games and a football table which was a hit with the kids

my kids loved it

to stay, the restaurant downstairs has delicious food with really nice portion sizes, and the breakfasts were

the rooms were well equipped with kitchen facilities, wireless phone chargers , bluetooth speaker and record

kitchen needed to be better equipped

microwave, fridge, dishwasher and 2 hob top in the kitchen

the breakfast is filling and delicious and available until 15:00 p

travelling with kids can be stressful (even more so with kids with additional needs

location. early check in

i requested late check out and it was a huff and moan, a simple polite answer would of been appreciated

room for a night in newtown, central to countless bars/restaurants/attractions

i used the pool, sauna and steam room mid afternoon and had it to myself

- gym was the bare minimum

staff at reception and breakfast

however, we also used their laundry service and they lost our laundry

loved the shower with aveda products, very comfortable bed, complimentary treats and the gym was very handy

we got lost trying to find the gym but a member of staff (a guy who looked like maintenance) saw us and took

central location,loved the kitchen facilities,spacious room, modern,friendly staff would def stay

centrally located , validated parking, excellent facilities, great to have access to a laundry

it has very convenient self serve laundry facilities and their taxi call button brings a cab in minutes

were very friendly, room was spacious, clean & well equipped, lovely to have a small kitchen area, really liked

love that there are laundry facilities but the dryer heats the clothes well - just takes forever to actually

the food both at breakfast and at the restaurant/room service was really good

we were allowed early check in which was wonderful, thank you .

plus connecting door to next room, locked, but leaked all the noise from family with kids in next room

- 24 hour room service was very nice as we arrived late at night and my kids were hungry

dirty laundry left out in the rain in trolleys in the car park

had a laugh with the kids

staff and always happy to help free wifi location (perfect with easy access to plenty of edinburgh's finest

local access to town and station. breakfast was excellent highly recommended

had a laugh with the kids

him and his collegaue got the sofa bed ready for the kids

continental breakfast plus included options from the kitchen

small things in my opinion, but worth noting - shower cabin a bit small - wifi doesn't have a good reception on

we were very comfortable in the apartment, my kids called it home for two days

the wifi didn't work in our room but it did in the bar and foyer so wasn't a big deal.

apartment out with the hotel (approx 3 doors down) on basement level which was excellent with kids as you felt

the first floor bar (complete with dj) provided a chilled ambience on arrival

while the staff there were excellent and they kindly offered complimentary breakfast and a dinner, the room

the bar was very expensive - over 32 for a cocktail and two non alcoholic drinks.

con didn t work in room, battle to get the breakfast we d pre-booked, over enthusiastic waiting staff clearing

breakfast was decent