the room was over the bar which could have been noisy on a busy night.

lovely hotel,spotless,nice room comfy bed.lovely bar & staff

i went to bar to ask where my drink was

00 and the lady behind the bar could not have been more helpful

evening meal in the bar the night we arrived, and breakfast in the morning was excellent

location near the train station in wallyford (10mins away and free parking ) and then only 10 mins into city centre (+) parking there is free and easy (+)20 return from musselburgh station with free parking, also perfect location for musselburgh (+) breakfast was first class, and lots of parking space (*) parking in edinburgh is expensive (+) plenty of parking (+) large private parking (+) free parking (+)ancient building perfect interior very tasteful. surrounded by gardens, plenty of parking (-) it was also very clean in the room, the bathroom, the grounds, and the parking lot

all the staff were excellent from reception, dining, room service, bar and even the gardener gave me a nod

room service also available

there was no info pack in the room regarding wifi or room service and organising a menu and subsequent snack was very frustrating as they were short

wifi in the room was intermittent.

would of sped up meal time considerbly as there were only a few staff to take orders at the bar who wernt there very much

our request for early check in as attending a wedding

plenty of car park space. air conditioning in the room. early check in.

place where you eat melville inn the selection of foods if you have kids there isn't great small dislike as this eas a great

the reception staff were very helpful in arranging an early check in for us

breakfast excellent, tasting menu one evening excellent

on one side the views extend to the a golf course, to the field which hosts the bull cows and the stunning old brick coach house

beautiful rooms, spectacular location, golf course bordering the property, great food & friendly helpful staff

the breakfast and high tea were sublime

great mini bar snacks plus biscuits & cakes in our room wuth a great coffee machine

it offers a lot of good parking

helpful staff, great location with free parking, good breakfasts and dinners, great atmosphere

parking

free station parking

beds, linens, size, quiet, great parking

great location, good rooms, plenty of ev chargers.

special shout out to tulgeran (i hope i got the spelling right) who mans the bar area , and achilles

nice pet friendly hotel - beds, bows and treats, our room was on the first floor next to the bar and we were worried it would be noisy, but it wasn't

the cool and calm kyle was wonderfully engaging in looking after us guests in the beautiful bar area in the evening

beautiful building, the breakfast area and the bar were so nice

i had my 2 kids with me(3 and 5)and the room was almost too small for them

no common area to chill out in when kids in bed

just got the family day pass when we wanted to travel and only cost 10 pounds for a family of 3 kids and 2 adults

stayed a couple of times, once with two kids visiting family nearby at really short notice, and at the price on agoda, would definitely

we supped to check-out around 8:00am the internet was blocked and hot water switch-off i and my kids found this situation very stressful

parking proximity to holy rood park breakfast recently refurbished and spacious room

we had arrived in a mini bus and parking was not an issue - thank goodness

welcome, parking, accessibility, room, bed and shower room, breakfast...first class.

we had private and safe parking

the price for the location and parking was excellent

massive bed, it was comfy. allow me to early check in and my car stays after check out.

bar in lounge full with drinks

early check in was arranged for me to be able to attend an online lecture, appreciated this.

loved the honesty bar in the lounge

we had a 2 night weekend booking mid november and were pleased that staff had accommodated our early check in request

welcome when we arrived, excellent cooked scottish breakfast every day (but if you want, you can also help yourself with water, juice, cereals etc

owners were lovely, great location & good value. breakfast was excellent.

friendly owners, room glorious, beds so comfortable and breakfast a delight

laundry service available if required

there is some variety in breakfast options, including freshly cooked breakfast

neighborhood, superfriendly and accommodating owners, walkable (20 mins to city center), great kitchen, small breakfast included

kitchen appliances would have been useful like a microwave oven or toaster and a bigger fridge

kitchen

great location and in particular great parking great pet beds and lovely rooms

perfect location! free parking, which is rare with a city centre hotel.

great location, friendly and helpful staff, good food, free car parking

top location and lovely room. and the icing on the cake is free parking.

there s plenty of parking which is free and two minutes walk to the tram stop to go in the centre of edinburgh

breakfast, so very disappointing

fingal is a great experience all round and breakfast is worth a mention to

breakfast was great and the close proximity of the tram is ideal to explore the city.

i highly recommend the brûlée porridge with whiskey for breakfast

the dinner and breakfast were of the highest quality and standard

the bar could have stayed open a bit later.

the food was outstanding, best breakfast ever, by far, great choice, and local fresh produce

staff were fantastic and caring the breakfast was excellent (had the porridge with heather honey) bedroom/bathroom was clean + bed was

the room was lovely and warm comfy bed supper breakfast friendly staff.

to hang clothes in the room and the tv channels were not set up, but the young lady behind the bar solved the issue